Credit: iStockphoto.com

Credit: iStockphoto.com

New federal guidelines for school subject area that emphasize alternatives to suspension and expulsion were announced Wednesday by U.Due south. Secretary of Pedagogy Arne Duncan, who called on schools to "rethink" their disciplinary approaches.

The guidelines issued by the Office of Civil Rights are in response to national data that show that African American students are three times as likely as white students to be suspended or expelled, often for similar nonviolent offenses. Students of color and those with disabilities are disproportionately suspended, Duncan said in a video announcing the new guidelines. He called for fair and appropriate discipline policies that keep students in schoolhouse and learning.

The response to the new guidelines was positive from advocates for change.

"This groundbreaking action by the nation's didactics and justice leaders volition help shift the focus of school discipline to prevention and support, instead of harsh school discipline practices that have caused a nationwide suspension epidemic," said Michael Soller, director of communications for Public Counsel, a public interest law business firm based in Los Angeles. "These guidelines ship a stiff message that ending bigotry in school discipline isn't simply a local issue; information technology'due south an consequence for our entire state and our nation."

The guidelines too say that schools are liable for bigotry caused by police force officers or school "resource officers" and pushes school districts to analyze the roles of police, Soller said. "It says school officials, not police, should be the first responders on discipline matters," he said.

The guidelines clarify the rules districts must follow under Title Four and Title Half dozen of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964, which forbid discriminatory practices. In terms of discipline, schools cannot have policies that overtly target certain students, just they also would be breaking federal law if certain racial groups are disproportionately affected by the rules.

The Function of Civil Rights tin can initiate compliance reviews based on complaints that a district's academic or disciplinary practices are doubtable. For example, Los Angeles Unified is currently nether a voluntary agreement with the Office of Civil Rights to improve the academic accomplishment of English learners and African American students. Oakland Unified besides faced a compliance review and voluntarily agreed to implement more than positive disciplinary practices to end disproportionate suspensions and expulsions of African American students.

Along with the guidelines, the department included resource for districts and schools on alternatives to suspensions and expulsions, such as setting loftier expectations for behavior, involving parents, and promoting social and emotional learning strategies. Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, said that schools need funds to implement such policies.

"The federal government made many positive suggestions," Weingarten said in a argument. "Only policies in a vacuum without bodily resource and support will not succeed."

Others are concerned that the new guidelines will compromise school safe.

"While at that place are legitimate issues on suspensions, expulsions, and arrests, will politicizing it push the pendulum to an extreme that volition result in increased discipline problems and schoolhouse crimes because administrators are more than focused on keeping their numbers downwardly and staying out of the federal crosshairs?" said Kenneth S. Trump, the president of National Schoolhouse Safe and Security Services, in a statement. "Will educators solve the numbers problem but not bargain with the behavior and crime problems behind this issue?"

California legislators and schoolhouse administrators have been wrestling with these issues for the by few years. Legislators have passed laws, including Assembly Bill 1729, introduced by Assemblyman Tom Ammiano, D-San Francisco, which encourage districts to implement positive discipline policies such equally restorative practices where misbehaving students are asked to brand amends to anyone they have harmed. For instance, a educatee who disrupts a form might apologize to the instructor and stay after class to assistance the teacher prepare for the adjacent mean solar day.

On this year's legislative agenda is AB 420, introduced by Assemblyman Roger Dickinson, D-Sacramento, that would limit the suspension of students for "willful defiance" of schoolhouse authorities, considered a subjective category that has been used disproportionately to append African American students.

As indicated in an EdSource survey of the xxx largest districts, many districts have been implementing alternative disciplinary policies over the past few years, and other districts are merely starting to embrace them. "Some California schools take heard the wake-up call," Soller said in an email. "Information technology's time for California leaders to take the adjacent step and challenge all our schools to end discrimination in subject area for all students, non just some of them."

To get more reports similar this i, click hither to sign upward for EdSource'due south no-cost daily email on latest developments in education.